Friday, July 4, 2008

Kitchen / Food and Drink - Soda-Club Fountain Jet Home Soda Maker

Happy Independence Day, America!

Of course, for many people in the U.S. of A., the 4th of July means barbecue!

If you're sipping a nice ice-cold soda while grilling today, think about all the plastic and aluminum required to hold your fizzy drinks. (Of course, you can recycle the packaging, but still...)

How can you kick the bottle and can habit? One solution (my first choice, actually) is to use tap water and tea bags to make nice big pitchers of iced tea.

But if you've got to have the bubbly stuff, at least you can ditch most of the packaging with a Soda-Club® home soda maker.

The Soda-Club machine basically consists of a canister of carbon-dioxide inside a plastic dispenser. You add tap water to the 1-liter bottles that come with the machine, inject carbonation into the water with the press of a button and then add whatever syrup or other flavoring you like. Voila - practically instant soda!

When you're finished with your soda, just rinse out and reuse the bottle. (That would section #2 of the famous "Reduce, Reuse, Recycle" slogan.)

As Soda-Club points out, if the Green movement doesn't want people buying bottled water, why is it OK to buy bottled soda? Why not just make your own soda at home with tap water, a CO2 cylinder and a dash of flavored syrup?

Well, for one thing, most people who drink soda like a particular brand or taste. IMHO, Soda-Club's flavors don't quite measure up to some of the name brand soda tastes that have been refined over decades. (On the bright side though, Soda-Club does claim that its soda mixes contain no high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS) and have 2/3-fewer carbs, calories and sugar than store-bought soda. We presume they mean non-diet kinds of soda...)

Also, if you're just an occasional soda-drinker, you may not want the hassle of mixing your own soda when you get an urge for a glass of the fizzy stuff.

Soda-Club could be great fun for kids who'll get to see what goes into making a bottle of soda, or it could even be a (minor) hit at cocktail parties, but be warned that the 1-liter bottles won't quench a thirsty crowd. You might want to get a couple of extra bottles if you do plan on using Soda-Club for a party.

Our verdict: For heavy soda drinkers who also want to play a smaller role in the plastic and aluminum waste stream, Soda-Club could be a Revolutionary product. But it still probably won't get its own public holiday.

Now go enjoy your fireworks.

Where to buy:
Online at Soda-Club's website. Offline at Boater's World stores nationwide and assorted other retail outlets.

2 comments:

lee said...

um, i don't wanna be negative or nothing, but you do know that CO2 is that greenhouse gas everyone's been talking about, right?

So just because there's "less" waste with this product (personally i would think that the embodied energy in recycling PET is less much much less than recycling spent steel CO2 cannisters). There's still the issue that you are promoting something that essentially releases CO2 into the air (all for what? to please our feed tubes?)

i cant really see this as a green product no matter how you slice it

Aaron said...

Hi Lee,

Thanks for your comment and for reading this site. I appreciate your efforts to be un-negative! :)

I did agonize a bit over whether (and how) to review the Soda-Club machine.

Ultimately, one purpose of this blog is to help people move the needle and lead greener lives.

For some people, that will mean switching from regular soda to organic soda, or from bottled water to tap water.

For some people, I think it might mean the difference between hopping in the car and burning fossil fuels to pick up a couple bottles of soda at the convenience store versus filling a bottle with tap water and soda mix and making soda at home.

As for the CO2 use, I believe it would be used either at the factory in making store bought soda or at home. It might be equally bad to use it at home, but it's not worse (as far as I can tell) than buying store-bought soda from a greenhouse gas perspective.

I also think the amount of CO2 involved in making one bottle of soda is probably extremely minimal. I believe one of the steel canisters is supposed to last for 100 liters of soda. (Again, you're reusing the same plastic soda bottle and just rinsing it out between uses.)

Also, CO2 is not a completely harmful gas. As Wikipedia points out, "Carbon dioxide is produced by all animals, plants, fungi and microorganisms during respiration and is used by plants during photosynthesis."

Oh and as for the CO2 canisters, they're refillable I believe. You do have to send them back to a factory to be refilled (whereupon you're sent a new one), but I don't think they need to be melted down and recreated each time in the same way that PET bottles are recycled...

Sorry for such a long response. But I think you raised some good points in your comment and wanted to give your comment the attention it deserved.

Hope you'll subscribe to the blog and continue to visit - and comment!

- Aaron Dalton, 1GreenProduct.com